A/C Machine Accuracy

A/C Machine Accuracy: The Consequence of an Incorrect Charge

To maximize the potential of the new refrigerants, the precision of system operation became more important than before.

Old habits are hard to break, and when you grow up and learn things in a certain way, it can be difficult to retrain yourself down the road. Such is often the case and was with me when it came to automotive A/C systems and R-12 refrigerant. R-12 simply worked well. I always believed it had a better heat transfer rate than subsequent refrigerants, but did it really? Scientifically I’ve heard arguments that go both ways, and rather than fall in that black hole, I’ll just leave it at that.

What I do know is that R-12 cooled big cars and the refrigerant systems had massive capacities. The refrigerant worked well and being down a few ounces really didn’t matter. When you charged these systems, you didn’t worry about exact amounts. You kept an eye on the sight glass, and when the bubbles were gone, the system was charged. It was a process that was far from anything resembling precision, but it didn’t matter. You’d have ice cubes coming out the dash vents in no time.

Don’t get the wrong idea. This isn’t a complaint about ditching R-12. Environmentally we needed to switch to a different refrigerant, and I completely agree with it, but it took a while to adjust my mindset on A/C service. Here’s what made the big difference: R-134a and R-1234yf have different thermal heat transfer rates, i.e., they are chemically different than R-12 and, as a result, the systems were designed to operate at slightly different pressures.

Old 2-cylinder compressor
How times have changed: This old 2-cylinder compressor weighs more than some lawnmower engines.

In order to maximize the potential of the new refrigerants, the precision of system operation became far more important than before. You might say that R-12 systems were much more forgiving, but with the new refrigerants, it became critical to balance the heat transfer rates of the evaporator and condenser. Condenser efficiency is a key component to proper operation, and if the evaporator is more efficient and draws more heat out than the condenser can release, system operation will suffer.

In addition to all this, A/C system capacity is far less than it used to be. Instead of capacities that were multiple pounds, most systems operate with only 12-16 ounces of refrigerant, for many reasons. Compressors are much smaller and more efficient in order to save weight and increase fuel economy. Smaller hoses and lines allow for more precise pressure control, and lower capacities mean less effect on the environment in the event of refrigerant loss.

old R-12 system
2 lbs., 14 oz. of R-12 was required for this old R-12 system, but there was plenty of wiggle room.

Add all this together and the accuracy of your A/C machine becomes an important topic. The most obvious consequence of an incorrect charge is the effect on the cooling ability of the system. Even the slightest over or under charge will throw off the designed pressures of the system, resulting in an immediate effect on duct temperature. A low charge also means low oil circulation, which can cause damage to the A/C compressor.

Refgrigerent caution sticker
Modern system capacities are much lower, and accuracy is critical for proper operation.

Accuracy during refrigerant recovery is an often-overlooked aspect. If an A/C machine reports that it has recovered all refrigerant, but has not actually done so, this presents a number of problems. One, if you open the system, the remaining refrigerant is released into the atmosphere. Two, it’s money lost, and three, if you are performing a recharge service, you could very likely overcharge the system.

No matter how you stack it, an incorrect A/C charge will cost you money, either now or in the long run. How can it be avoided?

The latest standards for A/C equipment are SAE J2788 for R-134a and SAE J2843 for R-1234yf. Machines meeting these standards are required to be able to recover 95% of system refrigerant in 30 minutes or less without applying any heat to the system, and their required accuracy for refrigerant weight is plus or minus .5 ounces.

None of us likes to buy new equipment, but if we’re going to continue to work on modern A/C systems, we’ll have no choice but to make sure our equipment meets these standards. A final point to remember is that all this equipment requires regular calibration and, in many cases, it’s recommended by the manufacturer once a month. This should be part of your normal shop maintenance routine. TS

You May Also Like

Scan Tool Tech

While systems can and will differ, here’s a look at common ADAS features, their general configurations and calibration requirements.

scan tool tech

Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS) require the use of a scan tool for diagnostics, and the majority of the time, it’s required for post-repair calibration. ADAS, like any other system, requires a diagnostic routine, which begins with a base knowledge of the system. Knowing ADAS will help understand fault symptoms and scan tool data for the most efficient diagnosis.While systems can and will differ, here’s a look at common ADAS features, their general configurations and calibration requirements.Parking assist sensors, of which there can be more than one, are generally located in the front and rear bumpers. They are the inputs that affect active parking assist and parking collision warnings. Any time they are disturbed in any manner, a static calibration must be performed with a scan tool.Side object sensors, sometimes called collision avoidance sensors, are commonly located in the rear bumper. These sensors provide input for blind spot warnings, lane change alerts and rear cross traffic warnings. Static calibration with a scan tool is required when these are removed or replaced.Rear vision cameras will be located in the rear decklid, liftgate or tailgate, and act as either a backup camera alone, or part of a surround view system if the vehicle is so equipped. These cameras generally require a dynamic calibration, and no scan tool is required.A forward-looking camera is sometimes located behind the grille, and usually part of a surround view system. These too do not require a scan tool, but a dynamic calibration must be performed when they are removed or replaced.Different ADAS features may have dedicated control modules which can be located in various areas, often behind interior panels. As with most control modules, these require scan tool programming when replaced and, depending on the system, both static and dynamic calibrations may be required.The Haptic Seat Motor creates the vibration to provide a safety alert for blind spot, forward collision, lane departure, lane keep assist, parking collision and rear cross traffic warnings. These motors, sometimes called seat warning actuators, generally require no type of calibration.Cameras located in a sideview mirror are part of surround view systems. These require calibration when removed or replaced, but most of them dynamic, and no scan tool is required.The steering angle sensor located in the steering column is an input for lane keep assistance, and a static calibration is required with a scan tool any time it is removed or replaced, or any time a wheel alignment is performed.Last, but not least, is the front view, or forward-looking camera located in the windshield area. This camera is a vital part of adaptive cruise control, automatic emergency braking, automatic high beam headlights, forward collision and lane departure warnings, and lane keeping assistance. A scan tool and static and dynamic calibration are required after removal and replacement, but also after windshield removal or replacement, or any service that affects the ride height of the vehicle. TS

Battery Chargers: Which one do you need?

Modern battery chargers adapt to diverse battery types and needs.

charging a car battery
When Your Digital is Dead: Reading Calipers and Micrometers

Need a refresher? Here’s a crash course.

Inside the Scan Tool

A look at the internal and external components that affect performance and durability.

data chip
Nylon Fuel Line Repair

Quality should be number one when making decisions.

Other Posts

Clutch “No Release” Problems

Poor clutch release makes it difficult to start and stop the vehicle or change gears.

Fine-Tuning Your Wheel Balancing Process

The first step to a smooth ride and well-balanced tire has nothing to do with the balancer.

Upgrade Your Air System: It’s Easier Than You Think

Improving your shop airflow is only a benefit, unless you like to spend more time, work harder and make less money.

air flow tubes
Why ECU Reflashing Needs Certain Power Levels

A reflash power supply is not designed to jumpstart the vehicle.