Can We Have Too Many Tools?

Can We Have Too Many Tools?

Like many technicians, after years in the field, I'm still trying to organize my tools.

Last month, we started this new column called “Not a Prybar or Punch.” It’s a column about the life of an automotive technician, from good to bad, to funny and frustrating. Many of these will be true stories and lessons I’ve learned the hard way over the years, and some of them will just be my opinion.

If you like what I say, or if you don’t, feel free to drop me a line and let me know. I’m always happy to share other people’s viewpoints.

Like many technicians, I’ve spent my entire life trying to figure out how to organize my tools. I’ve spent countless dollars on every type of organizational product in the book, and while most of them work great, I still find myself looking for a way to make it better.

After all these years, you would think I’d have it figured out, but every time I get things organized, somehow it gets away from me, as it did again over the last year. Finally, I figured out the problem. I have too many tools! Personally, I used to never think that was possible, but now I realize it is, and it was my latest organization project that made it all clear.

A few weeks ago, I started reorganizing my tools. On top of the fact that my garage was a complete disaster from too many projects, I had bought more tools, and just had no place to put them. I had also purchased a tool grid system and many bags of the accessories, and even though I was eager to install it, I felt like it would take a long time, so I was avoiding the project.

It was time to get things in order and I decided installing the tool grid was the place to start. I only purchased the grid for the top drawer of my toolbox since it was full front-to-back with sockets, stored on everything from traditional rails to socket peg trays. I knew there was a lot of space being lost but didn’t know how much I could reclaim using the grid system. I figured I’d try the sockets first, and if it worked for them, I’d think about getting more for the rest of the box.

So, I dug into the project and emptied the top drawer. I cut the tool grid boards to fit and once I had them in place, I started to lay things out. Long story short, it turned out great! It took me a while to find the “rhythm” of what I was doing, but once I did, it went quickly. The sockets that formerly took up the entire drawer were reduced to taking up only half of the space!

But it wasn’t the grid that made me discover the root of the problem, it was going through all the sockets one by one as I laid out the drawer. Why do I have two of these, I continuously asked? I don’t need this, I kept murmuring to myself. Where did all this extra stuff come from?

That alone almost did it, but then I started working on the rest of the box and decided I was going to move my screwdrivers around. That’s when the lightning bolt struck. I had a whole drawer full of screwdrivers and, without counting, I’d say a close estimate was 50. That means there were about 35 more than I ever use.

I have a standard eight-piece set of screwdrivers, two different ratcheting screwdrivers, an extra-long Phillips, extra-long flat blade, two stubby screwdrivers and a pocket screwdriver that I use all the time. That’s it. These are all I ever use, and I end up digging through a cluttered drawer of extras just to find one of these when I need it. I use these particular ones because they are the high-quality professional tools I invested in when I decided on a career as an auto technician.

So, how did I get so many? The extra ones aren’t junk by any means, they are good screwdrivers, but they are not as good as the ones I consider professional tools. There’s the occasional one that I found under the hood of a car, and many that were either given to me as a gift or that I bought before I was in the industry. And there’s at least half a dozen pocket screwdrivers that were Christmas gifts from tool dealers.

It must be some kind of strange addiction to hoard tools like this, but it’s time to get them out of my toolbox. They’ll either go into small portable tool kits in the trunk of a car, or I’ll give them to someone who needs some. Just think of the time I’ll save not digging through a pile of screwdrivers to find the one I need. Not to mention, it’ll be easier to spot a missing one when I’m cleaning up.

It turns out, my plier drawer was the same way with many pairs I haven’t used in years. Then, with all the extra space in my top drawer, I was able to lay out and store all my ratchets and extensions, which also turned out great, but in the process, I realized there, too, I had multiple extras. Many of these were professional quality, and I know I made the decision to buy them, many times just because of a sale or unexplained impulse, but the fact remains; there are only a few that I use. I just have too many tools.

I must be a tool dealer’s dream. So, I’m thinning out the tools I never use, my toolbox looks better than ever, I’ve increased my efficiency and I have all kinds of space opening up for new stuff that I actually need. Now I can get back to what I’m good at — buying tools. TS

You May Also Like

Refrigerant Oil Has to Be Right

Oil type is just as important as oil capacity.

Three bottles of refrigerant oil

Air conditioning (A/C) is like electricity. It can be one of the more difficult things to grasp because there’s a lot going on behind the scenes. The physical components are easy to understand; we can remove and replace them all day long. But just like electricity has resistance, voltage and current flow, A/C has temperature and pressure relationships and there’s a lot of science involved in the theoretical operation.When we focus on the refrigerant oil itself, it’s had its share of misconceptions over the years and it didn’t help that A/C systems of old, i.e., R-12 systems, were a little more forgiving on the service side of things. But, you can throw that all out the window, and the only thing that matters now with today’s A/C systems, the oil, as well as the refrigerant capacities, leave no room for error.Over the past 30 years, A/C has been continuously evolving. Different refrigerants aside, the most obvious change has been the volume of refrigerant which the systems require. It’s half, and in some cases less than half of what they used to be, meaning today’s systems must operate much more efficiently (that scientific stuff) in order to cool the same or better as they used to. The best part is, they do! They’re getting the job done with half the juice, but what about the oil capacity? It’s also approximately half of what it used to be.Since the oil lubricates the compressor, is half enough? And, how does the oil charge affect the efficiency of the rest of the system? With most older compressors, only about 50% of the system oil capacity was present in the compressor at any point. It would naturally collect in the case, but they didn’t have a specific means to retain it, so it was picked up by the refrigerant and carried continuously around the system. Larger oil capacities ensured there was always enough to supply the compressor.Modern compressors feature oil retention technology to keep more oil within the compressor case itself, and today’s compressors retain approximately 75% of the oil capacity of the system. When adequate oil is retained in the compressor, less is needed in the system, and the overall oil capacity is greatly reduced.Reducing the amount of oil is one of the reasons that we have been able to achieve increased efficiency with less refrigerant. Oil creates a thermal lining on the surface of the evaporator and condenser, which reduces the heat exchange efficiency of the components. By reducing the amount of oil coating the inside surfaces, heat exchange efficiency is increased, so less refrigerant can be used to obtain the same result.The accumulator connection: Orifice tube systems utilize an accumulator after the evaporator (as opposed to expansion valve systems that utilize a receiver/drier after the condenser). Since compressors are not able to compress liquid, the purpose of the accumulator is to capture any excess liquid refrigerant that exits the evaporator (a normal characteristic of orifice tube systems), and it also plays a critical role in compressor lubrication and cooling. Any liquid refrigerant and oil that enter the accumulator drops to the bottom. A tube inside the accumulator picks up the refrigerant vapor from the top, loops down to the bottom and back up to exit again from the top. At the base of this tube is a small orifice. The orifice allows the vapor to pick up small amounts of liquid refrigerant and oil that have collected at the bottom and carry it back to the compressor, replenishing the oil and providing additional cooling to the compressor.This is critical because if a system is undercharged, there won’t be any excess liquid refrigerant exiting the evaporator. If no liquid refrigerant covers the base of the tube inside the accumulator, it won’t pick up the oil to return it to the compressor.Sticking together: Refrigerant oil gets easily carried throughout the system in the liquid refrigerant, however a change in chemical state occurs when refrigerant evaporates. On old R-12 systems, the R-12 refrigerant and oil molecules had a strong attraction when evaporation occurred, so the oil would stick to the vapor molecules and get carried back to the compressor.A big change that occurred starting with the R-134a systems, was that the refrigerant carries the oil along when in a liquid state, but when it evaporates, it doesn’t retain a strong bond with the oil. Some hangs on, but some doesn’t. As the refrigerant charge gets low over time, the liquid refrigerant in the evaporator also gets lower, and the oil tends to drop out and pool in the bottom of the evaporator. This causes a lack of lubrication at the compressor.

Open Up Your Scan Tool Options

Buying a scan tool can be difficult.

Inside the Tool: How Wrenches are Made

Today’s tools are built to withstand levels of stress well above that of years ago.

Hot Billets Ready for Forging. Courtesy Beta Tools
Can You Diagnose a TPMS Radio Wave?

There are a couple of approaches and tools you can use to diagnose a TPMS radio wave.

radio tower
Programming Options

Let’s help keep the code secure and your sanity intact.

Other Posts

Testing is a Tool

Testing sure has become a lot easier with time.

pencil writing on test
Let Me Get My Violin

We find ourselves playing the role as listeners, counselors, advisors, and compassionate, caring people.

How Accurate Is Your Click-Style Torque Wrench?

Due to how the click-style wrench makes the click, it can lose its factory calibration.

Torque wrench
Change is Coming, Join the Ride

TechShop has launched two new video series, and one video podcast series.

Photo of Nadine Battah